The False Charcoal Burner (Russula grisea) is a medium to large brittlegill with a smooth, shiny cap in shades of greyish-violet, violet and olive, 5-11 cm across, convex when young and becoming depressed. The gills are crowded, pale yellow and brittle, and the stem is white.
It grows from Jun to Oct in broadleaf woodland, mycorrhizal with sweet chestnut, beech, oak and lime. It is widespread but uncommon in the UK.
It is easily mistaken for the Charcoal Burner (Russula cyanoxantha), which has greasy, flexible gills that rarely fork, whereas R. grisea has brittle gills that often fork. Other grey, violet or green-capped brittlegills, such as Russula parazurea and Russula ionochlora, can also look similar and often need microscopic features to separate them. The taste ranges from mild to acrid, and as the species cannot safely be told from its relatives in the field, it should not be eaten.
| Season | ||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
Distribution
Widespread but uncommon
Habitat
Mycorrhizal with sweet chestnut, beech, oak and lime in broadleaf woodland, on clay or calcareous soils.
Etymology
Russula comes from the Latin russus, meaning red, with a diminutive ending, so "reddish". It refers to the red caps of many brittlegills. The specific epithet grisea comes from Medieval Latin griseus, meaning grey, and refers to the grey tones of the cap.
Associates
Castanea, Fagus, Quercus, Tilia
Cap
The cap surface is smooth and shiny, with greyish-violet, violet and olive tones that often blend together. It is convex at first and becomes depressed with age.
| Colour | |
|---|---|
| Shape | convex, depressed |
| Surface | smooth |
| Width | 5 - 11 cm |
| Peeling | 1/2 |
Gills
The gills are thin, very brittle and often forking. They are sometimes tinted rose-violet near the cap margin.
| Colour | |
|---|---|
| Spacing | crowded |
Flesh
White, firm and brittle. The taste is mild, though it can be slightly acrid in young gills.
| Odour | Not distinctive |
|---|---|
| Taste | Mild, acrid |
Stem
The stem is firm, stocky and rather short. It is white, but is sometimes tinted lilac in parts.
| Colour |
|---|
Macrochemicals
Iron sulphate (FeSO4) turns the flesh bright rust, and guaiac turns it blue.
| FeSO4 | |
|---|---|
| Guaiac |
Spores
The spores are subglobose and warty, with warts up to 1.25 µm high. There are few thick connectives or chains of warts joining them.
| Colour | |
|---|---|
| Shape | subglobose |
| Ornamentation | warty |
| Size | 6.5-8 x 5.5-6.5 μm |
Microscopic Features
The gill edge has pointed, spindle-shaped cells. The hyphae of the cap surface are cylindrical with thread-like terminal cells. The cap-surface cystidia are cylindrical or club-shaped with a terminal appendage.
| Dermatocystidia | clavate, cylindrical |
|---|
Classification
- ↳ Phylum: Basidiomycota
- ↳ Subphylum: Agaricomycotina
- ↳ Class: Agaricomycetes
- ↳ Order: Russulales
- ↳ Family: Russulaceae
- ↳ Genus: Russula
Synonyms
- Agaricus griseus Batsch
- Agaricus griseus Pers.
- False Charcoal Burner Vernacular, English
- Russula furcata var. pictipes Cooke
- Russula grisea (Pers. ex Secr.) Fr.
- Russula palumbina Paulet ex Quél.
- Russula palumbina Quel.
Reference Sources
G. Kibby, M. Tortelli, F. Hampe, C. V. Soler (2026) The Genus Russula in Great Britain with keys to species. Geoffrey Kibby.
T. Læssøe, J. H. Peterson (2019) Fungi of Temperate Europe Vol. 1. Princeton University Press.